Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly Review

Genre: Survival Horror | Developer: Tecmo | Release Date: 2003

Published by Ubisoft (for the PlayStation 2) and Microsoft Game Studios (for the Xbox), the game follows Mio Amakura who's trapped in a ghost-filled village cursed by a failed ritual as she explores the village searching for her sister Mayu while fighting hostile ghosts.

Campaign

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly delivers a deeply unsettling and emotional journey, following twin sisters Mio and Mayu Amakura as they explore the eerie, abandoned Minakami Village. The narrative masterfully blends Japanese folklore with psychological horror, as the sisters become entangled in a tragic ritual involving the Crimson Sacrifice. 

The story is layered with twists, effectively weaving past and present through chilling visions and fragmented memories. While the protagonists' dynamic is engaging—mirroring the village’s ill-fated twins, Sae and Yae—the game would have benefited from branching storylines, offering different fates based on player choices. 

The multiple endings are effective, albeit deeply tragic, but having more interactive elements and varied outcomes could have added replay value. While some puzzles feel forced and backtracking can be frustrating, the hauntingly immersive story makes this one of the best ghost-themed horror games to date.

Rating: 4 out of 5

Gameplay 

The Fatal Frame series is renowned for its unique combat system, and Crimson Butterfly continues that tradition with the Camera Obscura, a supernatural device that allows Mio to capture and exorcise ghosts. This mechanic is both thrilling and nerve-wracking, requiring players to face spirits head-on to deal maximum damage. While the RPG elements tied to the Camera Obscura (such as upgrades and film types) add depth, the system takes some getting used to. 

The difficulty levels provide a welcome challenge, but the game could have introduced more diverse combat mechanics to keep engagements fresh. Puzzles range from intriguing to needlessly complex, sometimes disrupting the pacing. 

Additionally, a more refined UI for tracking objectives and lore elements would have enhanced the overall experience. The fixed camera angles and movement controls, while effective in intensifying dread, can be frustrating, especially in tight spaces. More interactivity with the world—such as uncovering hidden secrets within the environment—could have deepened the immersion.

Rating: 3 out of 5

Production

Visually, Fatal Frame II still holds up remarkably well, thanks to its detailed environments and hauntingly atmospheric art direction. The village exudes an overwhelming sense of dread, with decrepit houses and shadowed hallways that make every step feel like a descent into madness. However, many houses have a similar aesthetic, making some areas feel repetitive. Ghost animations, while effective in execution, appear stiff and dated. Cinematics, on the other hand, are beautifully crafted and significantly enhance the storytelling. 

The sound design is one of the game’s strongest aspects, with eerie ambient noises, unsettling whispers, and a deeply ominous soundtrack amplifying the fear factor. Voice performances are strong, conveying both the emotional depth of the story and the terror of the characters. While Mio’s timid nature may not appeal to all players, she remains a likable and well-developed protagonist.

Rating: 4 out of 5

The Verdict

In the end, Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly remains one of the most terrifying and emotionally gripping horror games ever made. While some gameplay mechanics feel dated and backtracking can be tedious, its masterfully crafted atmosphere, strong story, and unique combat system make it a standout in the survival horror genre. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly gets 4 out of 5.

Comments